home | pg. 1 | pg. 2 | pg. 3 | pg. 4 | pg. 5 | pg. 6 | pg. 7 | pg. 8 | pg. 9 | pg. 10 | pg. 11 | pg. 12 | pg. 13 | pg. 14 | pg. 15 | pg. 16 | pg. 17 | notes | Transylvania detail 1 | Transylvania detail 2 | Wolcott detail | Bibliography | D. Gorton Homepage | Jane Adams Homepage
The New Deal Farm Security Administration in the Lower Mississippi Delta:
Reading the Photographic Record
by
Jane Adams
D. Gorton

Other absences expose sensibilities and agendas of the time. Several scholars have studied the FSA photographers and photographs, using the available records, such as Roy Stryker’s instructions to the photographers. Their work was always harnessed to national narratives, in which the local and particular lifted off of its specificity and became exemplary of some universal. This was the era of modernism, both “high” and “low.”

Scott, in his influential book Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed, analyzes what he terms "high modernism." High modernists, he claims, placed their confidence in a science-based progress, believing that the rational design of society and nature would allow virtually unlimited satisfaction of human needs. This ideology, when harnessed to a state apparatus, Scott observed, centralized power in ways that was fundamentally anti-democratic and insensitive to local variability.

Jess Gilbert, in "Low Modernism and the Agrarian New Deal," argued that, in contrast to New Deal leaders like Rex Tugwell, the founder of the Resettlement Administration, who could be termed a "high modernist," other U.S. Department of Agriculture leaders were "low modernists" -- people who sought to build local knowledge into state procedures, and who retained a skepticism about the efficacy of science as a solution to all human problems.


Lake Dick, Arkansas, was the most centralized RA/FSA project we have found in the Delta. The clients lived in lots fronting on the lake and operated the farm as a single unit under the direction of a farm manager.
This distinction of both sensibility and ideology can be seen in the FSA photographers. One indication of this is how the human subjects are treated by the photographer: Few of the people photographed appear with their names.

This is partly an artifact of field conditions, which required the photographers to write captions a considerable time after they shot the photo. (see http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/ fsahtml/fabout.html for a description of the process.)

More important, most of the photographers appear to have viewed the people they shot as exemplary of a larger story, not people whose own lives – and therefore names – were important. Notably, Marion Post Wolcott identified many of her subjects by name. But Lange’s Migrant Mother, like her plantation owner cum overseer, remained nameless until their fame spurred others – or themselves – to name them.


The Library of Congress has a detailed explanation of this series here http://www.loc.gov/rr/print/list/ 128_migm.html.

Anyone who has worked with local photo collections knows that people devote enormous care to naming everyone possible. The gap between this sensibility – of remembering one’s friends and neighbors, and the documentary photographer’s desire to capture an exemplary moment – reveals the disconnect between the FSA photographers’ cosmopolitan view of their subjects and the subjective reality of those they photographed. That critique has been made over and over, and we do not need to repeat it here.

We are more concerned, in our research, to unpack the social data available inside the photographs, particularly in reference to the dynamics of class and race. Our research has shown us that the experience of the white sharecroppers who were given opportunity by the FSA projects varied greatly from that of Mr. Partee and his fellow white supremacists, as well as from the cosmopolitan intellectuals who, in the 1930s, were animated by a romance of “the people,” of whom mostly white tenant farmers were one important subset.


Lunchtime for cotton hoers. Dorothea Lange. June 1937. LC-USF34- 017456-E
Page 16

home | pg. 1 | pg. 2 | pg. 3 | pg. 4 | pg. 5 | pg. 6 | pg. 7 | pg. 8 | pg. 9 | pg. 10 | pg. 11 | pg. 12 | pg. 13 | pg. 14 | pg. 15 | pg. 16 | pg. 17 | notes | Bibliography | Transylvania detail 1 | Transylvania detail 2 | Wolcott detail |